or to participate
Brian A3 years ago
I'm glad the transition went mostly well! The one thing I miss from Substack is the ability to see where links are going, which the Beehiiv redirect links make impossible. If a link is going to a paywalled site that I won't be able to read, I'd like to know that before clicking it. Or if a link is going to YouTube, I'd likely skip it if I knew ahead of time.
Other than that the experience has been great!
hunter walk3 years ago
thanks - happy to be a subscriber regardless of platform
Jason McClure3 years ago
Very informative!
Melody S3 years ago
I love analytics and business-of-newsletter stuff! Thank you so much for sharing!
Kurt M3 years ago
Thanks for making the switch! New paid subscriber here. Good luck on beehiiv! 👍
Molly White3 years ago
I love this report on how the migration went! Super informative, and I'm glad it seems to have been an overall positive experience (albeit with some bumps in the road).
Sean Wallace3 years ago
IMO the email address with www in it is way more of a 🚩🚩 than writing directly in the CMS. Interesting post though, I always really appreciate the “how this business works (or doesn’t)” insights. Thanks!
Peter Vader3 years ago
Not in the newsletter business but definitely in a migrating-systems one so I enjoyed you taking us through your experience. Both in the helpful amount of detail and how terrific a writer you are.
Sam S3 years ago
No questions, just - this was really interesting to read, so I’m glad it was long!
Caz Hart3 years ago
In theory, it's correct to say that Substack provides tech support for both writers and readers, in practice, they don't respond to readers. I'll assume they support readers if there's a payment issue, but otherwise, they ignore readers.

Rusty Foster3 years ago
That's interesting. I was always under the impression that they were assisting readers with any problems they had. Maybe they just had fewer problems.
Naduh Buhbahduh3 years ago
I am a first time paying newsletter subscriber. And that's pretty much because you were one of the only authors to reply when I asked a bunch of my favorites if they were thinking about moving. If that hadn't happened, I would never have realized you aren't just some random Rusty but you are that Rusty and I've been hoovering free content from you all the way back to Kuro5hin days. Thanks for moving and for all the other stuff too...here and also back in the stone age era.
Sarah Jay3 years ago
Glad you made the move and it’s working out pretty well!
cf cfe3 years ago
dude, i am glad you made the change. i will miss the "Our Regrettable Platform" comments, but you're pretty good at that sleek dagger-like swipe so i'm sure you'll find your spot to shoot your shot.
Andrew Janjigian3 years ago
This is great, Rusty, especially this bit:
"But I didn’t realize how much of a drag on my enthusiasm the repetitive cycle of knowing the founder posted something stupid again because I got a new flurry of cancellations had become, until it wasn’t my problem anymore. It’s hard to describe a dysfunctional platform relationship, and it’s equally hard to describe one that feels productive and well-aligned."
Filing this one away (with a dozen others) for when I have the bandwidth to extract myself from the other place, thanks for sharing.
Sara Goldsmith 3 years ago
From my personal (subscriber) perspective, this transition was totally seamless, which is exactly what I would hope for. Thanks for the invisible work that went into making it so.

Rusty Foster3 years ago
That's so good to hear. Kind of by definition I only heard from people who did have problems, so it's easy to over-index on that and feel like everyone did.
Danielle M3 years ago
Not a content provider or a writer, but have been a reader since the tiny letter days. Really appreciate the invite into this transition!
Clara Parkes3 years ago
Thank you so much for taking the time to write this. I have one project already on Ghost, and it’s been brilliant. The project I launched on Substack back in Ye Olde Early 2020 needs to be moved, I’ve just been paralyzed by fear of making some mistake and stopping its heart from beating. You have been a huge help. Waving to you, with gratitude, from here in Maine!
Alex Dobrenko3 years ago
hey rusty its me alex i'm curious what you're seeing in terms of free subscribers coming from the beehiv network if at all? That's obviously a big draw of Substack and I know beehiv does something similar (where you pay per referral maybe?)

Rusty Foster3 years ago
Yeah beehiiv has some paid promo tools that I haven't tried out yet. It also has Recommendations, like substack has, where you can suggest other Beehiiv newsletters to new subscribers. So far I've seen zero incoming and zero outgoing from me to others from that, which is surprising. It worked pretty well on Substack. So either I'm doing something wrong or it's not working here at all.
Caitlin Boulter3 years ago
This is exactly the kind of post I was hoping we’d get at some point about the platform switch, because I’ve been wondering and looking for accounts like these from writers I know and trust to hear about how the great Substack exodus is working - thanks very much for writing it!
Lauren Lipsay3 years ago
no questions, just appreciation :) thanks for getting out of there
D B3 years ago
I have to stop subscribing because of my budget not because of Substack but if I ever have more money, I will be much more inclined to resubscribe with you out of that place. Which is ironic because in theory, I have a Substack. But it’s free, so I figure the Nazis are subsidizing me.
Is Is3 years ago
Thank you for doing all this work! I've been a Tabs reader since 2021, but I just couldn't bring myself to give Substack money. I was one of the people who switched to paid right after you moved and was very pleased to finally do so.
Mary F3 years ago
I always love learning how the hotdogs are made! Interesting report and I'm glad you're getting a well deserved raise.
GG GG3 years ago
Thanks for sharing these details, and I’m so happy not to be giving money to Substack anymore. But can you please please please tell Beehiv they NEED to let paid subscriber login w/a password to read paywalled posts? The current method of requiring them to email you a link, then you have to go check your email and click a link, is ridiculous, and a huge drag for those of us who normally read by checking todayintabs.com. Thank you for everything!
Rusty FosterAuthor3 years ago
Yeah the user account management stuff is not great. I hope it’s a thing they’re currently working on, but idk for sure.
Danny Noonan3 years ago
Rustomer Service
Alison H3 years ago
ruh roh